First Choice Caribbean

First Choice Caribbean brings an authentic slice of the islands right to the heart of Troy, NY. Nestled at 451 Fulton St, this vibrant Caribbean restaurant is a beloved destination for those craving richly spiced, soulful dishes that transport you straight to the Caribbean shores. The moment you step inside, you’re embraced by a casual and welcoming atmosphere where the focus is truly on the food—and the food here doesn’t disappoint.

The menu is a treasure trove of classic Caribbean favorites, each bursting with bold, layered flavors. Their legendary Oxtail with Rice Peas, Cabbage, and Plantains is a standout—a tender, slow-cooked masterpiece simmered in herbs and spices that melts in your mouth, perfectly complemented by the earthy sweet plantains and the gently seasoned rice and peas. If seafood more your style, dishes like Ackee & Saltfish and Jerk Shrimp offer an exciting medley of textures and tastes, with fresh, flaky fish or succulent shrimp paired alongside traditional sides, delivering vibrant, comforting meals that leave you utterly satisfied.

For meat lovers, the menu offers a tempting range from Pepper Steak to hearty Curry Goat, each served with the classic Caribbean sides that are the hallmark of a well-rounded plate. The appetizers offer everything from crispy Fish & Chips to savory Beef and Chicken Patties, ideal for a quick snack or a flavorful start to your meal.

Customers consistently highlight the impeccable seasoning and the perfect balance of heat and sweetness in every dish. Mike h raves about the jerk chicken, noting its perfectly cooked spice and flavor paired with “bomb” plantains, while Ashanti L appreciates the consistent quality, especially the delightful chicken and sweet plantains. The comforting combination of cabbage, callaloo, and rice, though sometimes understated, completes each plate in a nourishing and hearty way, as noted by J Keal who reflects on the deeply satisfying nature of their meals.

One can’t help but feel the passion and care that goes into every meal here. Tahseen Hasan’s praise for the “legendary” oxtail speaks volumes about the craftsmanship behind their offerings, making First Choice Caribbean not just a restaurant, but a culinary refuge for those seeking authentic Caribbean flavors in a friendly, down-to-earth environment. Even amid a bustling day, their food arrives quickly and warm to your doorstep, a testament to their dedication as Vi Hu has experienced through delivery services.

If you’re in Troy and yearning for Caribbean comfort food that delivers on both flavor and experience, First Choice Caribbean is a must-visit. The perfect blend of savory, spicy, and sweet awaits you here, promising a genuine taste of the islands that lingers long after your last bite.